Table of contents:
- Before choosing a heat pump
- 1. Danfoss DHP-H Opti Pro + 10
- 2. NIBE F1245–8
- 3. Viessmann Vitocal 222-G BWT 221. A08
- 4. SunDue SDW-03E
- 5. Buderus Logatherm WPS 9
- 6. Gebwell T15
- 7. Henk 160 H SS
- Heat pump summary table
Video: Heat Pump - Choosing The Best Model For Your Home
2023 Author: Douglas Hoggarth | [email protected]. Last modified: 2023-05-24 11:23
- Before choosing a heat pump
- 1. Danfoss DHP-H Opti Pro + 10
- 2. NIBE F1245–8
- 3. Viessmann Vitocal 222-G BWT 221. A08
- 4. SunDue SDW-03E
- 5. Buderus Logatherm WPS 9
- 6. Gebwell T15
- 7. Henk 160 H SS
- Heat pump summary table
Since the attention to "clean energy" began to grow steadily, a large number of samples of equipment, both foreign and domestic, have appeared in the post-Soviet space. In most cases, the purchase of a heat pump is significantly cheaper than gasification of the site, and there is no question of comparing the efficiency of the operation of geothermal units with other heating systems.
Before choosing a heat pump
The most popular choice of Russian buyers is multifunctional heat pumps optimized for operation from different sources of geothermal heat. For many people, the decisive factor when choosing is the ability of the heat pump to provide the house with running hot water.
The power output range for most heat pumps is the same, and the higher the price in a number of typical equipment, the longer the service life between overhauls. The sign of a truly suitable piece of equipment is the best combination of the following operating parameters:
- COP (energy conversion factor). Determines the energy efficiency of the installation by comparing the ratio of temperatures in the primary and final heat exchange circuits with the electrical power required for operation, and the value of the coefficient set by the manufacturer is not real. The exact COP value can only be recorded during operation at a specific heat source temperature and temperature in the house. In most regions of Russia, it is acceptable to use devices capable of providing a COP value from 4.2 to 5.2. COP is a general and basic indicator of the operation of any heat pump, while it depends on the characteristics of individual units.
- Compressor capacity (m 3 / min);
- Rated electrical and thermal power of the installation (respectively, consumption and heat received);
- The boiling point of the refrigerant gas and its type;
- The power of circulation pumps and the presence of frequency control of the system;
- Controller type and functionality. It is better to choose a heat pump, the operation of all automation units in which is controlled by a microprocessor controller, which provides as many completely autonomous operating modes as possible for different climatic conditions.
Most suppliers order a heat pump through a questionnaire, so each unit is made individually. Therefore, we will compare seven universal equipment models from different popular manufacturers.
1. Danfoss DHP-H Opti Pro + 10
About the manufacturer
Danfoss is one of Europe's most renowned international companies. Thanks to the addition of a number of well-known manufacturers of climate technology, electronics and precision instruments to its composition, Danfoss fully controls the manufacture of all components and has its own research and development center.
About model and series
DHP-H Opti Pro + 10 can be the best choice for small cottages and country houses. The series is distinguished by the use of Opti technology in devices, which reduces energy consumption for the operation of the compressor and circulation pumps, as well as HGW technology, which has realized the possibility of heating water from high-temperature gas. Downhole probes, horizontal contour or geothermal waters can be used as a source of low-grade heat. Also, this series is distinguished by the presence of a storage tank of 180 liters.
Features and basic parameters
The lineup is represented by four devices with different heat outputs ranging from 5.8 to 13 kW. The COP value is different for all models, for the DHP-H Opti Pro + 10 we are describing it is 5. The pump consumes 2.2 kW. Differences of this pump from analogues:
- The water is heated by a special design boiler that allows you to heat a full tank in less than 2 hours.
- There is a heating element for additional heating of running water or increasing the productivity of the installation in severe frost. No redundant heating units are required.
- The pump has a very good arrangement of actuators inside the casing, and therefore differs in small overall dimensions (LxWxH): 596x690x1845 mm with a device weight of 220 kg.
2. NIBE F1245–8
About the manufacturer
NIBE is an international European brand with headquarters in Sweden and more than half a century of history. The motto of the company for decades has been the slogan “Provide every home with comfortable heat and hot water”. The peculiarity of the manufacturer is the presence of its own industrial complexes for the production of the main units and mechanisms of heat pumps, as well as cooperation with leaders in the manufacture of climatic equipment: Bristol, Mitsubishi Electric and Copeland. Characteristically, the company has completely abandoned the manufacture of equipment based on the combustion of fossil fuels.
About model and series
Like many popular models, F1245-8 has small overall dimensions (LxWxH): 600x600x1800 mm. The pump provides a maximum supplied thermal power of up to 7 kW without switching on additional heating, which makes it possible to use it in country houses and office premises with a total area of up to 100 m 2. The design includes a hot water boiler with a capacity of 180 liters. These are serial samples, which are manufactured by analogy with the most common European models of HP, however, the technological units and mechanisms involved in NIBE pumps are characterized by a much longer service life, which explains their high cost.
Features and basic parameters
The F1245 pump series consists of four units with a maximum power of 6, 8, 10 and 12 kW respectively. COP for these units ranges from 3.5 to 5, and the electric heating element of additional heating has four power levels from 2 to 9 kW. Also F1245-8 has a number of differences from similar units:
- The thermal circuit of hot water supply copes well when operating in a flow-through mode up to 4 l / min.
- The pump is fully adapted to any of the four low-grade heat sources.
- The electronic control circuit is distinguished by a high degree of reliability and provides effective control of the pump resources at a heating medium temperature of the heating circuit up to 50 ° C.
- The pump provides for additional upgrades by including an open solar collector in the thermal conversion chain.
3. Viessmann Vitocal 222-G BWT 221. A08
About the manufacturer
The international company Viessmann was founded in 1917 and has been actively working on the serial production of heat pumps for more than forty years. Through the efforts of twelve thousand employees, the manufacturer not only entered the international arena as a reliable supplier of climate control equipment for eleven countries of the world, but also established cooperation with the largest installation and service organizations.
About model and series
The built-in storage tank has a capacity of 170 liters. The minimum COP value for these heat pumps is 4.3. It is optimized for heating small residential areas in temperate or continental climates. The main emphasis in this model is made on comfort during operation, setting parameters and operating modes. Installation of the pump can be carried out by the owners themselves using common fitting parts and plumbing. All three models are adapted for the use of solar collectors in the primary heat exchange circuit.
Features and basic parameters
With overall dimensions of 680x600x1830 mm, the BWT 221. A08 pump has an enviably high rated thermal power: 5.9, 7.7 or 10 kW for three representatives of this series of heating equipment. The units weigh 250–256 kilograms and can be divided into component parts for convenient transportation, in addition:
- Brine is used as a heat carrier in the primary circuit, which means that groundwater cannot be a source of geothermal heat.
- The Vitocal 222-G differs from analogs in the most user-friendly control interface in the controller with a carefully designed mnemonic. In addition, the control module itself can be removed from the boiler body and placed within five meters from it.
- The maximum water temperature in the heating system and hot water circuit is 60 ° C.
- One of the lowest noise indicators (43 dB) among heat pumps allows these units to be installed directly in residential premises.
4. SunDue SDW-03E
About the manufacturer
SunDue is a manufacturer of heat pumps in the CIS. The Kazakhstani company is guided in its activity by the advanced achievements of science and technology, which, together with the quality of the equipment produced, which is traditional for the former Soviet republic, allows it to boldly compete with the world's leading brands. Thus, the reliability and quality of products is not inferior to European standards, although the price is much lower. In addition to heat pumps, Ust-Kamenogorsk produces special fittings, borehole probes, pipes for ground heat exchangers and other components in the required range.
About model and series
The best examples of units are used in SunDue heat pumps, as in European models. For example, the SDW-03 series is equipped with Japanese EVI Sanyo compressors and German-made Lenze frequency converters. SunDue doesn't really care about the compactness of its devices. If in Europe it is customary to complete equipment in vertical cases, thereby preserving the maximum usable area, then SDW-03 has an almost equilateral shape, although the overall dimensions remain relatively small (LxWxH): 830x510x760 mm.
Features and basic parameters
In SunDue heat pumps, technical components are freely positioned, which made it possible to realize an excellent sound insulation system (noise level 37 dB) and facilitate access to the main units of the device for ease of repair and maintenance. The COP indicator is 4.5, that is, with a maximum of 12 kW of output heat power, the pump consumes up to 2.6 kW of electricity. Also SDW-03E provides:
- Heating water in the heating system up to 65 ° C.
- Efficient heating of water for domestic needs in a flow-through mode due to an indirect heating heat exchanger. The storage tank is missing.
- A modern control scheme for operating modes, taking into account the compensation of weather conditions, as well as soft start and stop of equipment.
5. Buderus Logatherm WPS 9
About the manufacturer
Buderus is a German company with almost 180 years of history and a relatively recent appearance on the Russian market. The production of heating equipment was made possible by the merger with Bosh. Today, the concern produces climatic equipment of exceptional quality, in particular - new generation heat pumps, in the design of which the best examples of compressor equipment and control systems are used.
About model and series
The Logatherm WPS 9 has a simple setup and typical design, although the emphasis is on excellent reliability and durability. The series includes five devices of different power from 6 to 17 kW. These heat pumps are designed to heat detached cottages and mansions, as well as office and industrial premises, with a total area of up to 120 m 2. There is a built-in storage tank for hot water with a capacity of 185 liters. The pump is designed to use only geothermal heat with low potential and has a closed circuit with brine, which means that groundwater cannot be used in the primary heat exchanger.
Features and basic parameters
The maximum COP value in this series of pumps is 4.8. Overall dimensions (LxWxH): 600x645x1800 mm. The rated consumption of the compressor is 2 kW, there is additional heating using electric heating elements with two power levels for 6 and 9 kW. The pumps in operation are quite noisy (49 dB), and therefore it is better to install them in a separate combustion room. Also, the Logatherm WPS 9 pump is characterized by a number of features:
- It has four pumps that circulate hot water in the secondary circuit and brine in the primary circuit.
- The control system is very simple, the controller has a Russian-language interface.
- The digital controller can be easily integrated into general climate control circuits or into a smart home system.
- The maximum hot water temperature is 65 ° C.
6. Gebwell T15
About the manufacturer
Gebwell, located in Finland, produces heat pumps and accessories for them, as well as installs and maintains their devices. In addition, Gebwell is engaged in well drilling and horizontal soil heat transfer circuits. This is a relatively young company that managed to establish itself only from the best side, thanks to which it became possible to open numerous representative offices in Russia and the CIS countries.
About model and series
Although T-series pumps do not have a representative appearance, they have every reason for full-fledged competition with the best European manufacturers. Gebwell does not declare the full composition of the components and their manufacturer, but assures that the technical parameters of the intermediate circuit ensure the service life of the unit without major repairs up to 60 years.
Features and basic parameters
The unit is equipped with a Scroll compressor and has a rated thermal power of 16 kW. An additional heating element, which consumes 9 kW of electricity, allows you to heat a room with a total area of up to 230 m 2 even in severe frost. The features of this heat pump include:
- The optimal combination of overall dimensions (1100x596x642 mm) for installation in standard combustion rooms.
- Low weight of the unit (100 kg).
- Although the design does not include a storage tank, it can be installed separately. Such an opportunity for T-series pumps is provided by the manufacturer through the introduction of a number of accumulators with a capacity of 500 to 2000 liters. This is an added advantage in the flexibility of the installation.
- Gebwell supplies its equipment with all the necessary components for the installation of primary and secondary circuits, as well as boiler piping.
7. Henk 160 H SS
About the manufacturer
Henk pumps have been produced in Russia for a little over six years, but they are already very popular with installers and ordinary users. The lineup is very diverse - more than 80 varieties. The manufacturer focuses on the versatility of its equipment and the ability to integrate heat pumps into existing traditional heating systems both as backup heat sources and as main ones.
About model and series
Henk's main line of models includes eight units, each of which has up to ten different modifications. The production of pumps is carried out according to an individual order, taking into account all the needs and features of use. Heat pumps can be made in "Economy" and high-temperature versions, adapted for any type of low-grade heat sources, including air. There is no built-in storage tank: it was replaced by an efficient flow-through heat exchanger. The main advantage of these pumps is the selective configuration according to customer requirements, which allows avoiding the installation of unnecessary units, significantly reducing the cost of equipment.
Features and basic parameters
Henk 160 H SS is a standard complete set. Heating of water in the heating system and for hot water supply is possible up to 75 ° C. The device operates under the control of a microprocessor controller with a large number of preset modes. The thermal power of this pump is 12.6 kW, while the pump consumes up to 2.5 kW of electricity. The model has a three-phase power supply, in addition:
- An additional heat exchanger is included in the design.
- The pump can be installed in combined heating systems (radiator + underfloor heating)
- The controller has a separate control unit that guarantees soft start and stop of the unit, increasing the compressor life.
